There is Disney (TM) magic. This is the role that technology plays in our lives, in accomplishing things beyond the capabilities of the unaided human.
Then there is magic which to me could be as complex as communication through improvised music without words, sharing the same perception as someone else, or as seemingly simple as appreciating the beauty of nature and life.
For me the real "magic" of mushrooms is when you let yourself go deeply enough into the experience to see what you can get out of it. All about the effects.
I guess what I think of as magic is that which is subjective and perceptual.. that experience which cannot be quantified or empirically tested (at this point in time anyway)..