IJesusChrist
Holofractale de l'hypervérité
- Inscrit
- 22/7/08
- Messages
- 7 482
There are plenty of anarchistic "nations" around the world that distribute money evenly. They are not large but they do exist - and they are quite farther in extremity than those seen in communism or socialism, as far as "normal" goes.
See:
Freetown Christiania
Kibbutz
ASAP Spokane
Crimethinc
There are plenty of small communities everywhere that attempt to do it. One is off the island of rhode island which seems cool but I can't find it. There are a few in california/oregon/washington that are run completely off pot production, and then the ones above (some less important than others).
I suppose what I'm getting at is that socialism and communism can be implemented, however on a large scale someone always attempts to gain control. That is not a direct outcome of the system, or even an innate personality of people in general, it is simply our envision of of "what once was".
I will make the claim that these do not work because of our connection with old systems. When the "founding fathers" of europe moved over here they essentially wanted to be rid of monarchy - it had grown out of control and had become disgustingly powerful and biased.
Now, we are seeing (luckily not as bad as monarchies) the bias and inequality evoked by capitalism. The need for exponential wealth, or atleast the prospect of becoming rich is, in my opinion, the strongest driving forces for capitalism.
Once you realize you aren't going to invent the next ipod or own the next Microsoft, or find an old picasso in your garage - you start playing the lottery and cursing the system (my experience, anyways). Great aspirations of wealth drive us through school, work, and play - why I will not make claim.
I would like to make the claim that billionaires should never exist and that a philanthropy at its core is not beneficial, but I can't say it in great faith.
I'm going to have to sit this one out for a year and give anarchy and capitalism more thought.
See:
Freetown Christiania
Kibbutz
ASAP Spokane
Crimethinc
There are plenty of small communities everywhere that attempt to do it. One is off the island of rhode island which seems cool but I can't find it. There are a few in california/oregon/washington that are run completely off pot production, and then the ones above (some less important than others).
I suppose what I'm getting at is that socialism and communism can be implemented, however on a large scale someone always attempts to gain control. That is not a direct outcome of the system, or even an innate personality of people in general, it is simply our envision of of "what once was".
I will make the claim that these do not work because of our connection with old systems. When the "founding fathers" of europe moved over here they essentially wanted to be rid of monarchy - it had grown out of control and had become disgustingly powerful and biased.
Now, we are seeing (luckily not as bad as monarchies) the bias and inequality evoked by capitalism. The need for exponential wealth, or atleast the prospect of becoming rich is, in my opinion, the strongest driving forces for capitalism.
Once you realize you aren't going to invent the next ipod or own the next Microsoft, or find an old picasso in your garage - you start playing the lottery and cursing the system (my experience, anyways). Great aspirations of wealth drive us through school, work, and play - why I will not make claim.
I would like to make the claim that billionaires should never exist and that a philanthropy at its core is not beneficial, but I can't say it in great faith.
I'm going to have to sit this one out for a year and give anarchy and capitalism more thought.